Content on this page requires a newer version of Adobe Flash Player.

Get Adobe Flash player

FBI Director James Comey gives Historic speech 30 yrs late

The FBI is sending Hallmark cards to black community leaders. That’s the sense I got today as I watched the bureau’s director, James Comey, speaking about race and law enforcement. The speech was nice. The crowd was pleasant, privileged, and polite. Georgetown University was an appropriately prestigious and academic site to deliver this half-measure talk on law enforcement’s systemic murder and brutalization of an entire segment of the population.

This was the first time an FBI director has taken the time to speak about race this directly. It didn't happen during civil rights bombings, nor through the Jim Crow era of lynchings, nor in apologizing for COINTELPRO’s systemic assassination of African American civil rights leaders, nor in reconsidering the bogus claims against Assata Shakur that laughably make her one of “America’s Most Wanted,” nor through the war on drugs that militarized local cops and destabilized black communities in the 1980s, nor through the plantation system of corporate prisons, nor through the rapid expansion of hate crimes against immigrants and Muslim Americans since 9/11, nor during the horrendously disproportionate amount of death threats and assassination claims against President Obama over the past six years. It's late, but it's a start. 

The Guardian ran a solid timeline of his speech, "Hard Truths: Law Enforcement and Race," and the questions afterward. If you're looking to the transcript or the video for an earth-moving statement on race, you'll be disappointed. What you will see are a host of encomiums to law enforcement partway to acknowledging that cops' jobschasing criminals, being lied to all day, making flash decisionscan dim their view of humanity. (He also referenced the "Avenue Q" song "Everyone's a Little Bit Racist.") In this, at least, Comey's starting a serious conversation, even if it boils down to don't hate the players, hate the game.

"All of us in law enforcement must be honest enough to acknowledge that much of our history is not pretty," he said. And: "If we can’t help our latent biases, we can help our behavior in response to those instinctive reactions."

Even if the most profound aspect of the speech was Comey's choice to deliver it, he should be commended. He put words to paper recognizing the Kafkaesque tragedy black America has endured in urban areas since the great migration to the North in the early 20th century. While the South carried out its lynchings with ropes and white sheets, the urban North used badges and pistols.

Furthermore, Comey had to be the one to make this statement. We should take a moment to salute the recent fallen victims of "race discussions" who have tried to hold this sort of public forum. Attorney General Eric Holder received death threats from police for doing his job, when he opened an investigation into the Ferguson, Missouri police department. President Obama has tiptoed into this minefield a few times, reaping right-wing claims of race-baiting and left-wing deference to cops.

Remember when Prof. Henry Louis Gates was arrested for appearing to break into his own house? Obama made a simple remark about an internationally respected African American scholar's ability to enter his home without being arrested and paraded into a patrol car. Obama was excoriated; Gates was derided as an uppity intellectual for exercising his constitutional rights. Both esteemed menone a Harvard scholar, one the leader of the free worldhad to backtrack, stage a group photo-op with the white cop while sipping beers and smiling. It told America: "I’m not angrylook. I was just kidding about my rights."

Later we felt the public outrage of Trayvon Martin’s murder and the Sanford, Florida, police reluctance to so much as arrest the confessed and confirmed killer, George Zimmerman. President Obama remarked that Trayvon could be his son, as a sympathetic appeal to parents who do not want to see their children shot to death. Once again, the backlash silenced the most powerful man in the world. A vocal segment of America, it turns out, interprets anti-murder comments as anti-white.

We need white allies to step forward. We need them because a large population of destructively prejudiced citizens reject anything a woman says about rape and reproductive rights, or what a black person says about race, or what a Muslim says about peace. The words don’t penetrate.

Comey seeks to be that ally, to build a bridge Holder and Obama, because of their race, cannot. In gingerly stepping forward, he affirms that minority communitiesnot so far from Georgetown, in fact, but a world awayface unequal and deadly use of force.

Comey assumed the same submissive position that moderate leaders find themselves in during storms of right-wing insanity: Say something obvious about inequality. Make it clear that you love cops. Offer an anecdote about blacks and whites not being treated equally. Reaffirm your love for cops. Quickly utter the name “Obama” in a sentence with the word "admire." Last, be sure to mention for the back rows that, point of fact, you do love cops.

I’m processing this speech and wondering: What, now, are you going to do? We don't want to hear about collecting data on inequality. The data is in the dead bodies. The data is in the decades of black voices crying out under billy clubs and bullets. The data is in the riots after another cop walks away from a murder, after another not-guilty verdict.

The real work is in rewriting policies of enforcement and training. Comey's platform and prominence demand that he make a real commitment to policy change. For the next photo-op at a comfy American university, have the police chiefs of America's 20 largest cities stand behind the FBI director as he explains what they will enact over the next three years.

The speech Comey just gave needed to be made, ideally, 30 years ago. It was a start. Let's reserve placing laurels on Comey's brow until he commits to real change: Understanding only goes so far; data collection and convening committees only does so much. Abstract sympathy has yet to stop a bullet.


Article by Aurin Squire

More Articles
- X-Men: Apocalypse' Trounces Alice With $8.2M Thursday Night
- My Prince Experience - Tony Lesesne
- South Florida's new wave of Artistic talent - MUMFF
- FEDS reply to Apple
- Apple gets backing in FBI Phone case
- Star Wars: Episode VIII begins filming
- 2016 Mazda MX-5 Miata Named Best Sports Car for the Money
- FCC plan would give consumer control of set-top box
- Birth of a nation sells at Sundance for $17.5 Million
- Netflix subscribers set to hit 100mil by 2017
- Wednesday Night Comedy show to hit Miami
- NATPE 2016- Ted Sarandos of Netflix to moderate
- Tesla Model X - The high performance SUV
- Star Wars: The Force Awakens blasts away box office records
- Mazda to Showcase 'Car as Art' Exhibit
- The new Jeep Cherokee reinvigorates the 4x4
- Dr. Dorothy Bendross-Mindingall Volunteers Distribute Food
- CareerSource SFL gets top award- FL department of education
- Miami Dolphins Announce 50th Season all time team
- Mazda to Unveil All-New CX-9
- T-Mobile CEO thinks Blackberry might be making a comeback
- The new 2016 Nissan Titan XD takes a gamble
- National Flight Academy receives grant to educate youth
- Ford program recognized by White House initiative
- Understanding the power of the black consumer
- JM Family- Nominations for African American Achievers awards
- MUMFF 2015 - A major success
- Tesla gets a power updgrade on the Model S
- Runcible, a new smartphone shaped like a pocketwatch
- Dynamic performance of the Dodge Viper ACR 2016
- 2016 Mazda MX-5 Miata Fuel Economy Improves Dramatic 25%
- Future car stirs surprise in San Francisco
- LMG announces BECON TV as Newest Media Partner
- Miami Music Club - Giving drummers a chance to shine
- 5 Things to know about Miami's Tech Scene
- MIA Urban Music & Film Fest building an entertainment hub
- Dodge Viper GT3 proves fastest track car 2015
- Miami Urban Music and Film Festival 2015 is on the horizon
- MIA Urban Music & Film Festival September 25th & 26th
- One of the last Tuskegee Airmen Lt. Col. Williams passes
- Google Cardboard: How VR and AR could take off at Google IO
- Carol City High Defeats Dillard, 31-28
- ASPA Awards recipients 2015
- LMG Entertainment screens six projects at MMFM
- Miami Dolphins Rookies Rebuilding Together Event
- Mazda Reports Second-Best May Since 1996
- LMG is June 2015 Supplier of the Month at Broward College
- Stan Lee brings World of Superheroes to YouTube Spaces
- Surprising ways to lower your data usage
- Chevy Introduces 2016 Corvette Z06 C7.R
- Twitter designs new home page to flock new users
- Teen cuts into Apple watch band market
- Auto advances - The center of Ft. Lauderdale Auto Show 2015
- Ground breaking Rock Band game to make a return on next gen
- Blast Motion Signs Miami HEAT'S James Ennis
- Sea snails now make the strongest material on the planet
- JM Family Announces 2015 African American Achievers
- The Kingsmen Secret Service Review
- 50 Shades of Grey Review
- Hidden Apollo 11 artifacts found in Neil Armstrongs closet
- New VP and General Counsel - South East Toyota Distributors
- Comcast Highlights waves made in the Black Community
- Geoffrey Alardo named M-DCPS Teacher of the year
- Mazda names Jacob Brown Product Comm Specialist
- Black Tech week to position SFL to be a Hub for business
- New Media CEO Suzanne McDonald wins top intl Business Award
- Genetically modded mosquitoes could be released in the keys
- LMG visits NATPE 2015 - Day 1
- Benefits of Pressured Decision Making
- Should there be a limit to artistic and journalistic freedom
- AutoFOCUS - What's the Appeal; My top 3 features
- Family Fest: Seeds of the African Diaspora
- Streaming devices poised to dominate the viewing preference
- The World's Smallest PC
- Chris Rock's Top Five Review
- 6 Ways to kick off 2015 on a High Note
- Mazda reports best annual sales in 20 years
- Cable Giants Partner For Set-Top Box Data
- NATPE Announces on Pace Registration numbers for NATPE 2015
- Raquel Regalado visits Miami High During ‘Hour of Code
- Boxing expert James Smith signs deal w/ Creative Talent inc
- Miami Beach's Alton Road finally completed
- Gloria Estefan Talks Autobiographical Musical, On Your Feet!
- Space probe makes first ever landing onto a comet
- Live local and diverse entertainment ready to take the stage
- 13th Annual AutoFOCUS Awards Recap
- 6 Surprising facts about Diabetes
- MIA Artist to tag Middle School to raise money
- Stampede of 2015 Custom Ford Mustangs
- Miami's Tobacco Road Last Call after 102 Years
- VP of SAMA to be awarded at upcoming AutoFOCUS Awards
- 13th Annual AutoFOCUS Awards to leverage past/advance future
- American Sabor tells Mia's Latin Culture in American Music
- New Miami Central Train Station could become an urban Hub
- Premium Cable Content...without cable
- NATPE 2015 announces Market and Conference Theme
- MAZDA2 Wins Japan's Car of the year